| Round 1 vs Richmond Carlton 23. 12 (150) def Richmond 9. 13 (67) |
| Marc Murphy 43 Jarrad Waite 42 Eddie Betts 40 Simon Wiggins 37 Richard Hadley 36 Chris Judd 33 Bret Thornton 22 Matthew Kreuzer 20 Mitch Robinson 13 Bryce Gibbs 6 Aaron Joseph 6 |
| Round 2 vs Brisbane Carlton 18. 11 (119) def Brisbane 15. 10 (100) |
| Bryce Gibbs 40 Chris Judd 35 Bret Thornton 34 Marc Murphy 32 Jarrad Waite 27 Ryan Houlihan 26 Jordan Russell 25 Matthew Kreuzer 25 Richard Hadley 20 Brendan Fevola 5 |
| Round 3 vs Essendon Carlton 16.16 (112) def by Essendon 17.14 (116) |
| Chris Judd 43 Simon Wiggins 35 Matthew Kreuzer 28 Cameron Cloke 7 Brendan Fevola 4 |
| Round 4 vs Sydney Carlton 9.13 (67) def by Sydney 12.12 (84) |
| Jarrad Waite 29 Paul Bower 24 Chris Johnson 24 Simon Wiggins 20 Bret Thornton 16 Chris Judd 14 Matthew Kreuzer 6 Dennis Armfield 5 |
| Round 5 vs Western Bulldogs Carlton 21.7 (133) def Western Bulldogs 13.12 (90) |
| Marc Murphy 40 Matthew Kreuzer 39 Kade Simpson 38 Paul Bower 36 Andrew Carrazzo 32 Jordan Russell 26 Bryce Gibbs 20 Ryan Houlihan 19 Heath Scotland 18 Bret Thornton 6 Brendan Fevola 5 |
| Round 6 vs Hawthorn Carlton 15.12 (102) def by Hawthorn 16.10 (106) |
| Brendan Fevola 42 Paul Bower 40 Chris Judd 40 Nick Stevens 34 Andrew Carrazzo 32 Matthew Kreuzer 28 Dennis Armfield 15 Marc Murphy 10 |
| Round 7 vs Fremantle Carlton 11.15 (81) def by Fremantle 13.10 (88) |
| Chris Judd 38 Marc Murphy 38 Paul Bower 34 Bryce Gibbs 33 Denis Armfield 29 Matthew Kreuzer 25 Heath Scotland 5 |
| Round 8 vs Collingwood Carlton 16.8 (104) def Collingwood 7.11 (53) |
| Chris Judd 50 Kade Simpson 40 Heath Scotland 38 Bret Thornton 37 Bryce Gibbs 35 Marc Murphy 35 Mitch Robinson 24 Jarrad Waite 23 Paul Bower 7 Jordan Russell 6 |
| Round 9 vs Adelaide Carlton 8.12 (60) def by Adelaide 15.14 (104) |
| Paul Bower 38 Aaron Joseph 35 Matthew Kreuzer 29 Nick Stevens 18 |
| Round 10 vs West Coast Carlton 16.15 (111) def West Coast 10.10 (70) |
| Chris Judd 42 Aaron Joseph 39 Brendan Fevola 38 Paul Bower 37 Marc Murphy 36 Kade Simpson 35 Matthew Kreuzer 30 Ryan Houlihan 16 Nick Stevens 6 Brad Fisher 5 |
| Round 11 vs Brisbane Lions Carlton 16.16 (112) def Brisbane 16.10 (106) |
| Brendan Fevola 45 Chris Judd 45 Aaron Joseph 35 Bryce Gibbs 34 Marc Murphy 33 Dennis Armfield 25 Paul Bower 24 Steven Browne 18 Andrew Carrazzo 10 Bret Thornton 6 Jeff Garlett 4 |
| Round 12 vs St Kilda Carlton 14.11 (95) def by St Kilda 16.8 (104) |
| Kade Simpson 39 Bryce Gibbs 36 Michael Jamison 36 Shaun Grigg 33 Eddie Betts 32 Paul Bower 31 Aaron Joseph 29 Steven Browne 13 Setanta O';hAilpin 9 Chris Judd 6 Andrew Carrazzo 5 |
| Round 13 vs Essendon Carlton 9.13 (67) def by Essendon 21.10 (136) |
| Brad Fisher 29 Andrew Carrazzo 28 Eddie Betts 27 Setanta O'hAilpin 15 |
| Round 14 vs Fremantle Carlton 16.19 (115) def Fremantle 15.10 (100) |
| Chris Judd 45 Bryce Gibbs 42 Andrew Carrazzo 40 Setanta O’hAilpin 33 Jordan Russell 33 Eddie Betts 18 Marc Murphy 15 Shaun Hampson 4 Bret Thornton 4 |
| Round 15 vs Richmond Carlton 16.13 (109) def Richmond 12.17 (89) |
| Brendan Fevola 43 Jordan Russell 34 Eddie Betts 26 Matthew Kreuzer 26 Chris Judd 18 Shaun Hampson 8 Andrew Carrazzo 4 Bret Thornton 3 |
| Round 16 vs Sydney Carlton 19.10 (124) def Sydney 9.9 (63) |
| Kade Simpson 41 Chris Judd 38 Brendan Fevola 33 Matthew Kreuzer 32 Ryan Houlihan 26 Eddie Betts 24 Greg Bentley 13 Marc Murphy 12 Brad Fisher 9 Shaun Hampson 8 Joe Anderson 4 |
| Round 17 vs Collingwood Carlton 4.16 (40) def by Collingwood 14.10 (94) |
| Aaron Joseph 25 Bret Thornton 9 Paul Bower 8 Marc Murphy 6 Eddie Betts 2 Matthew Kreuzer 2 |
| Round 18 vs Nth Melbourne Carlton 14.10 (94) drew North Melb 11.18 (84) |
| Marc Murphy 37 Bryce Gibbs 37 Dennis Armfield 32 Richard Hadley 28 Nick Stevens 27 Ryan Houlihan 26 Brendan Fevola 18 Bret Thornton 5 |
| Round 19 vs Geelong Carlton 14.13 (97) def Geelong 8.14 (62) |
| Chris Judd 43 Bryce Gibbs 39 Bret Thornton 39 Brendan Fevola 37 Jordan Russell 36 Kade Simpson 36 Aaron Joseph 33 Marc Murphy 17 Ryan Houlihan 11 |
| Round 20 vs Port Adelaide Carlton 18.13 (121) def Port Adelaide 9.13 (67) |
| Bret Thornton 44 Marc Murphy 41 Jordan Russell 38 Bryce Gibbs 36 Brendan Fevola 33 Ryan Houlihan 33 Richard Hadley 29 Dennis Armfield 19 Andrew Carrazzo 16 |
| Round 21 vs Melbourne Carlton 24.9 (153) def Melbourne 15.6 (96) |
| Marc Murphy 36 Jordan Russell 36 Bryce Gibbs 33 Chris Judd 32 Brendan Fevola 30 Jeffery Garlett 30 Kade Simpson 18 Ryan Houlihan 12 Andrew Carrazzo 11 Heath Scotland 5 |
| Round 22 vs Adelaide Carlton 16.8 (104) def by Adelaide 27.14 (176) |
| Brendan Fevola 26 Bryce Gibbs 24 Andrew Carrazzo 17 Jordan Russell 16 Heath Scotland 14 Kade Simpson 2 Nick Stevens 2 |
| Elimination Final vs Brisbane Carlton 15.14 (104) def by Brisbane 16.15 (111) |
| Chris Judd 36 Ryan Houlihan 32 Jordan Russell 31 Brendan Fevola 31 Dennis Armfield 24 Matthew Kreuzer 21 Marc Murphy 20 Kade Simpson 5 Andrew Carrazzo 3 |
 |
The Voting Process Example: Player X receives 10 votes from each of the 5 members of Match Committee therefore he scores 50 votes for the round |
John Nicholls Medal: Round by Round
All the round by round voting in the 2009 John Nicholls Medal
